My Story: For the Love of a Child - Part 2 of 4

The Tennessee Court of Appeals vacated the trial court’s award of joint custody and ordered a new trial. While the appeal was pending, due to the lawsuit against Christy Little, the GAL, Chancellor Morris recused himself. The case was transferred to Circuit Court Judge Whit LaFon; Lafon was the uncle of former vice-president Al Gore. To make a long story short, Lafon was a shining example of why state judges should have to undergo the same scrutiny and appointment processes as federal judges. Many in the area referred to him as “Twit LaFon”. A google search of Whit Lafon reveals articles that LaFon was the subject of federal and state drug trafficking investigations; I do not know the veracity of those articles, but they make for some interesting reading. I was observing LaFon in court one time while he was berating a defendant for several minutes because of the defendant’s alleged actions overnight since the previous days hearing, and LaFon was about to put him in jail. The court clerk continually tried to get LaFon’s attention during this time when the clerk finally stated very loudly, “Your honor, this is not the same person from yesterday.”

While the appeal was pending, I became actively involved with the DAD organization, and wrote many Letters to the Editor advocating reform in child custody laws that were published in area newspapers. At the first pre-trial hearing in front of LaFon, LaFon strongly advised me to stop writing Letters to the Editor. It was clear at that time that LaFon had already made his decision in my case. I filed a complaint with the Tennessee Court of the Judiciary against LaFon. See letter from Disciplinary Counsel on Facebook page. LaFon was aware of the complaint at the new custody trial and actually questioned me for several minutes from the bench about the complaint. This was clearly improper and unethical. Lafon denied to the Court of the Judiciary that he had questioned me about the complaint, see Lafon’s response to the complaint attached on the Facebook page; however, the trial transcript proves otherwise, with the pertinent section starting with:
THE COURT: All right. Have you reported any judge to the disciplinary board?
MR. WINCHESTER: Yes, your Honor.
THE COURT: Who was that?
MR. WINCHESTER: Your Honor. The Court of the Judiciary was actually prepared to hold a hearing against LaFon in 1998; however, LaFon decided not to run for re-election (1998 was a judicial election year; this occurs in Tennessee every 8 years). Since LaFon was “retiring from the bench”, the Court of the Judiciary dismissed the complaint because the only thing that they could do to a retired judge would be a private reprimand, and the time and costs involved would not be worth it. Once again, the truth was legally suppressed.

Not surprisingly, LaFon awarded my ex-wife sole custody of my daughter, with me being granted standard visitation. So I went from having my daughter every other week to only having her every other week-end, two weeks during the summer, and alternating holidays. The day that decision was made was the worst day of my life at that point in time.

End of Part 2.